Industry says more engagement is needed on small pots consolidation
Image: William - stock.adobe.com
Pardon the Interruption
This article is just an example of the content available to mallowstreet members.
On average over 150 pieces of new content are published from across the industry per month on mallowstreet. Members get access to the latest developments, industry views and a range of in-depth research.
All the content on mallowstreet is accredited for CPD by the PMI and is available to trustees for free.
The pensions industry is calling for further engagement on small pots consolidation as the latest consultation by the government closes today, highlighting a need for ensuring protections are not lost in transfer and communications are tested.
The consultation published in September included proposals from how consolidator schemes will be authorised, to the digital infrastructure that will underpin the model.
It is suggesting a federated, scheme-led model with standards and rules set and governed by a central oversight body. At the time of the consultation, the government was still considering whether that function should be carried out by a public body, an existing organisation or an industry-led body within a statutory framework.
For members, the new framework would mean they will be offered a choice to opt out or implicitly agree with automatic consolidation of pots up to £1,000 after 12 months of inactivity. If they stay in the system, they can decide whether to accept the allocated default consolidator or select an alternative consolidator scheme. Members would also be given the option to keep a small pot if they plan to restart saving into it after more than 12 months.
A second Department for Work and Pensions consultation is planned for late 2027 or early 2028. This will consider detailed requirements for ceding schemes, the supervisory approach and finalised data standards among others.
Key questions still need to be answered
The proposed model found favour with Pensions UK, but the industry association said more industry engagement is necessary.
Director of policy and regulation Philip Brown said: “A federated, industry-delivered model offers a credible and pragmatic way forward for tackling the small pots problem. But this is the first step in the journey, not the final blueprint, and there are still important questions to resolve before consolidation can work safely and efficiently at scale."
He emphasised the need for consumer protection "from day one", value for savers, and ensuring pensions can move without losing possible guarantees or protections. Pensions UK also wants to make sure existing infrastructure is used rather than duplicated and is calling for sufficient testing.
"This ambition is achievable, but delivery needs certainty. The timetable needs to align with the wider reforms and give schemes sufficient time to prepare, test and implement the new arrangements," said Brown.
Trustees emphasise benefit protections, comms and admin capacity
The Association of Professional Pension Trustees supports an initial focus on default arrangements of large auto-enrolment schemes, with expansion after testing.
However, the APPT, too, stressed that protections must remain in place when pensions are transferred, citing protected pension ages, protected tax-free cash, retirement terms, guaranteed annuity rates, conversion terms and other promises.
“Member disengagement does not diminish the value of guarantees. Schemes should confirm that protections will be preserved or members have made an informed choice to relinquish them," said Tova Docherty, deputy chair of the APPT's legislation and regulation committee.
The APPT also argued that member communications need to spell out the consequences of inaction and should explain the receiving scheme, charges, investment changes, affected protections, choices and impartial guidance, with technical detail provided separately. The association supports two communication touchpoints and a 30-day notice period.
"Centrally tested templates should assess comprehension among disengaged members and those with differing financial literacy and accessibility needs," it added.
The trustee group stressed that receiving schemes need administrative capacity, resilience and asset-reconciliation controls, and "trustees need reliable information on service standards, charges, investments and member outcomes", calling for further engagement with the government and regulators.
ACA calls for extending inactivity threshold
The Association of Consulting Actuaries is concerned about the 12-month inactivity threshold, after the DWP said in the consultation that schemes will be expected “to take account of relevant information, potentially provided by employers” to temporarily exclude those inactive pots from consolidation where members are expected to resume saving, for example, during extended parental leave, planned career breaks or periods spent overseas.
In trying to make pension saving simpler, the government must avoid creating new problems, said Tess Page, who chairs the ACA’s defined contribution committee.
“A worker taking time out to raise a family should not find their pension has been moved unnecessarily simply because they crossed an arbitrary threshold. Once transfers become automatic, relatively small flaws in the system could affect thousands of savers. A modest extension to the inactivity period would provide a sensible safeguard without undermining the reforms,” said Page.
On member comms, the ACA recommends a standardised one-page summary, explaining the consolidation process and available choices. Notices should be tested for accessibility and scam resilience, with a way for savers to verify their authenticity without relying on links or QR codes, it said.
A key question will be who can act as a consolidator. The ACA believes this should be based on governance, operational capability and financial sustainability, rather than scheme size or the new value for money ratings while that framework is still bedding in.